Thursday, August 27
United Kingdom
2

A Winter Citrus Salad That Earns Its Place on the Table

Seasonal Cooking  |  September 16, 2026
A Winter Citrus Salad That Earns Its Place on the Table

Every January I go through the same small mourning for summer produce, and every January I get over it the moment I slice into a blood orange. Winter citrus is not a consolation prize. It is one of the best things about eating seasonally, and it arrives exactly when the rest of the market is at its most root-heavy and beige. A salad of oranges, shaved fennel, and oil-cured olives is the kind of thing that reminds you that January has its own pleasures, if you are willing to look for them.

The key is to treat the citrus like a proper ingredient rather than a garnish. Slice it into rounds, remove every trace of pith and membrane, and let the juices run into the bowl. Those juices become the base of the dressing, which means you need less oil and less acid than you would otherwise. The fennel goes in raw, shaved as thin as you can manage, and the olives bring the salt and the slight bitterness that keeps the whole thing from tipping into dessert.

Choosing and prepping the citrus

Mix your varieties if you can. Blood oranges give you color and a faint berry note; Cara Cara oranges are sweeter and more floral; grapefruit adds a bitterness that works beautifully against the fennel. Supreming them — cutting away the peel and pith with a knife, then slicing between the membranes — takes a few minutes and is worth every one of them. You end up with clean segments and a bowl of juice that you would otherwise have thrown away.

If you are short on time, you can simply peel and slice the oranges into rounds, pith and all. The salad will be slightly less elegant and entirely delicious. I have done it both ways on a weeknight and never regretted the shortcut.

Building the plate

Layer the citrus and fennel loosely rather than tossing them together, so the colors stay distinct and nothing gets bruised. Scatter the olives, add a few shavings of Pecorino or a crumble of ricotta salata if you want it to feel more substantial, and finish with good olive oil, a squeeze of lemon, and cracked black pepper. A few toasted almonds or pistachios add crunch. Mint or dill, torn over the top, makes it feel alive.

This salad is best within an hour of assembly, but it also holds up surprisingly well overnight in the fridge, which makes it a good thing to make on a Sunday and eat for lunch on Monday. The fennel softens, the citrus gives up more juice, and the olives season everything around them. Serve it alongside a bowl of soup, a piece of roasted fish, or a plate of beans and greens. In the middle of winter, it is the closest thing to sunlight on a plate.